ST. PAUL, Minn. — St. Paul officials plan to close two homeless encampments in December, displacing hundreds of people as city leaders cite safety concerns, winter weather and a growing number of emergency calls. Mayor Kaohly Her announced Thursday that the encampment along L’Orient Street will be cleared Dec. 8, followed by the encampment along Randolph Avenue on Dec. 15. The announcement comes four months after the closure of the city’s largest homeless encampment at Pig’s Eye Regional Park. Her said allowing people to remain outdoors through a Minnesota winter is not a humanitarian solution. She also pointed to complaints from nearby residents involving stolen bicycles, people sleeping or appearing naked in yards, and concerns about playground access because of drug activity. “These sites are not safe for the people staying in them, for our neighbors, for the workers who respond to them, and living outside in Minnesota winters is not a housing solution,” Her said during a news conference. Assistant Mayor Cedrick Baker estimated that between 235 and 250 people are living at the two encampments, although the numbers fluctuate. Ramsey County’s By the Name list puts the number at 367. “Closing encampments won’t end homelessness,” Her said. “The city can’t face a regional housing and public health crisis on its own.” City seeks funding for shelter beds Her has asked the City Council to redirect $1.6 million previously designated for downtown housing conversions to help move encampment residents into shelter beds. The proposed funding would supplement $1 million the council previously provided to Ramsey County. Council Member Cheniqua Johnson, who chairs the council’s budget committee, said Thursday that discussions with other council members were ongoing and the additional funding had not been guaranteed. Her’s proposal also includes $150,000 for a long-term housing plan. Ramsey County is expected to open low-barrier warming centers. A service navigation minibus will visit both encampments Thursday, allowing residents to privately meet with service providers and discuss treatment and housing options. Outreach workers will also help residents locate shelters that accommodate pets and explore alternative arrangements as shelter space becomes limited. Advocates criticize planned closures The announcement drew criticism from housing advocates and some City Council members, who argue that clearing the encampments without a comprehensive housing plan will simply move people elsewhere. A rally was planned outside City Hall Thursday, with organizers also collecting donations of medical supplies, tents, cots and other necessities. “Our homeless neighbors have nowhere else to go,” read a written statement forwarded by John Slade. “This eviction and destruction of their homes will take everything from them. They will be forced to start over. They will be traumatized, again, by the City and the cycles of harm sweeps cause.” Gary Lusso of Inver Grove Heights attended the rally and said housing advocates planned to help residents relocate wherever they chose. He said many people living at the encampments do not trust traditional shelter systems and may instead disperse throughout the city, potentially making it more difficult for outreach workers to connect them with services. Lusso said volunteers currently bring chopped wood and propane tanks to the encampments to help residents stay warm. “No matter where they’re gonna go, we’re gonna be there,” he said. Fire department reports hundreds of calls St. Paul Fire Chief Jeramiah Melquist said emergency responders have handled 206 incidents at the Randolph Avenue encampment and 118 at the L’Orient Street site since the Pig’s Eye encampment closed Aug. 5. The remote locations create additional challenges because emergency personnel must carry equipment and resources into the sites by hand. “We can have compassion for the people affected while also being clear these conditions put lives at risk, including the lives of those who live here and those who respond to help them,” Melquist said. Police Chief Axel Henry said the issue requires a humanitarian response rather than relying on citations and arrests. “We could legally go down and write tickets and arrest people all day long, but I don’t think anybody in our community or anybody in this city believes that that’s the way to solve this problem,” Henry said. Council members question city’s approach City Council Member HwaJeong Kim publicly criticized Her’s plan, pointing to a three-part homelessness response resolution approved by the council in October. That plan called for a 60-day strategic investment period, temporary low-barrier shelter during the winter and development of a permanent low-barrier, village-style shelter. Kim said the proposal had support from Ramsey County officials, state lawmakers and service providers. “Mayor Her is preparing to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars on encampment evictions that will just shift encampments from one block to another — money that could be used to get people into housing and provide desperately needed mental health services and addiction treatment,” Kim said. Council Member Molly Coleman also raised concerns, saying resources would be stretched thin if the city closed both encampments without a comprehensive plan for residents. She urged the city to maximize available funding to provide meaningful assistance and encouraged residents to contact her office about needed support. The October council resolution also called for the city to find an organization to operate a tiny-home shelter. Her said such a project could cost millions of dollars. The mayor said the city has been in contact with Gov.-elect Amy Klobuchar about the need for broader statewide and regional housing solutions. “Funding has to come from the different levels of government, and everyone has to pull the levers that they have in order to address this housing crisis,” Her said.