ONAMIA, MINNESOTA — Three years after a beloved rural physician was struck and killed by a hit-and-run driver while walking her dogs near her home in Onamia, investigators say they still have no new leads identifying the person responsible.
Dr. Cathy Donovan was walking her two dogs around dinnertime on November 13, 2023, near the southwest side of Lake Mille Lacs when a vehicle struck her. Donovan and one of her dogs died in the crash.
Donovan was a longtime rural medicine physician who was remembered for her love of the outdoors and her two children.
Mille Lacs County Sheriff Kyle Burton, who knew Donovan personally, said the investigation has been frustrating, with few clues emerging despite years of work.
“I thought we would have somebody in custody by now,” Burton said.
Investigators Have Exhausted Available Leads
Authorities have pursued multiple investigative methods, including reviewing cellphone tower data, obtaining geofence warrants and examining available surveillance footage in hopes of identifying vehicles that were in the area around the time of the crash.
Burton said investigators have exhausted the technology-based avenues available to them, although some drivers may have traveled routes that avoided the cameras in the area.
“There are other ways out of that area that would not have driven past those cameras, certainly, but for what we do have, we have explored what we can,” Burton said.
Investigators previously obtained search warrants involving an Edina man believed to have been driving a Tesla in the area around the time Donovan was killed.
However, DNA evidence and computer technology ultimately ruled him out as a suspect.
“At the time it was the best lead we had,” Burton said.
Family Still Waiting for Answers
Donovan’s death has left her family and the surrounding community searching for answers.
Her twin sister, Robin Councilman, previously spoke about their close relationship and the emotional toll of not knowing who was responsible.
“We knew what was going on sometimes without even saying,” Councilman said. “We need to know, need to stop worrying, every time the phone rings is this going to be the answer or not.”
A $25,000 reward remains available for information leading to the identification of the person responsible. Billboards throughout the area continue to ask anyone with information to come forward.
Burton said investigators remain hopeful that someone with knowledge of the crash will eventually provide information.
“It’s either somebody is going to take this to their grave or somebody out there knows about it and just hasn’t said anything yet,” he said.
How to Provide Information
Anyone with information about Donovan’s death is asked to contact:
* Mille Lacs County Sheriff’s Office: 320-983-8346
* Minnesota State Patrol Investigator Sgt. Jason Brown: 218-316-3026
The $25,000 reward remains in place as investigators continue seeking answers three years after the fatal hit-and-run.
Source: KARE 11; Mille Lacs County Sheriff’s Office.